Tuesday, September 6, 2016

Who's the real expert - CNBC TV 18 - 4 experts, 16 recommendations

It was 24th December 2015. CNBC TV 18 was broadcasting an investors' summit with 4 experts being anchored by Sonia Shenoy. Each expert - Tulsian, Porinju, Ambareesh and Prakash Diwan - had to talk about 4 long term multibagger picks of theirs.

Normally I don't listen to investor summits. Ever. Somehow, on a whim, I decided to watch it, note down the recommendations made, and compare performance of the expert recommendations after enough time had elapsed. I already have some favourites based no my gut feel but I thought let's subject them to a quantitative test to see if numbers justify my assessment. 

The detailed table of analysis is given below but first the summary of analysis for impatient readers.

Basis average, it seems Porinju Veliyath is the best expert among the famous four. However, Porinju is not as consistent a hitter as Mr Tulsian or Mr Baliga. His average is pulled up by Biocon, the best of 16 recommendations. Moreover he weakened his own case for title of best expert by mentioning that he is considering owning it but has not bought it yet. But he is a winner nevertheless. Sort of a batsman who follows 3 average innings with a double century.

That leaves SP Tulsian in next top spot who's outperformed Nifty 50 by 14%. Ambareesh has himself beaten Nifty 50 by a healthy 10%. Given that they gave just 4 recommendations, there is no statistical edge here but Mr Tulsian gets the 2nd spot based on pure numbers and nothing else.

Mind it though ;-) that performance is often measured in terms of risk-reward ratio and given lower variance in calls given by Mr Tulsian and Mr Baliga, any one of them could climb to top spot. However, once again, a small sample of 4 makes it impossible to determine a proxy for this ratio.

What's baffling is Prakash Diwan's performance. He's actually underperformed Nifty 50 by 6%; a nightmarish scenario if you happen to follow his recommendations. What's really pulled him down is his Dion Global recommendation which really did badly. Even without that though, he still ends up last, so the prize for worst recommendations goes to him. Anyone billionaire investing solely based on his recommendations, could find himself just a millionaire in a few years. 

It was personally very interesting for me to do this analysis. Based on my intuition, I have always placed SP Tulsian up there at the top and Ambareesh Baliga a little lower. And I always had suspicions that Prakash Diwan often produces half assed guesses and sometimes his analysis seems dishonest. But that was just a gut feel. It was gratifying to see that my intuition has been spot on. I have never followed Porinju and did not know what he could pull off. He definitely has a different way of making decisions compared to my other favourites so it makes sense that I track him too in future (only when he speaks directly. A number of times, other people attribute stuff to him which might be completely made up). 

Before you read the table below and make up your own mind about which one to pick for your own portfolio, just remember that winners of last 36 weeks are more likely to be the winners for next 3-10 years as well. Please don't fall for the cheap stuff automatically.

Personally I am going to add the following to my portfolio. No need to add Biocon as it has been there in my portfolio for almost a year.

  1. Jain Irrigation - current portfolio weak on agriculture theme so need to add this.
  2. Tata Global - apart from Porinju's argument that Cyrus Mistry might want to turn around this company (he might), coffee prices are also bottoming out for last 2 years, which can give an added boost during next 1-2 years, whenever coffee crop goes bad in a key grower country. Already have it. To add more.
  3. Anant Raj - here I am simply going by Porinju's assessment that company is real estate rich. Even in the best of days for real estate - pre 2008 - this company did not make money for shareholders in line with its valuations. 



Friday, May 2, 2014

e) What could be the most profitable setups from here on

 till May 2014 FNO series end (post elections) and thereafter

It's slightly late for this post but not too much. Ideally I should I have written this a week back. It happens to be 7th part of the series I started early March 2014. To start with, I am not giving any investing ideas except staying spread across real estate, short term debt, long term debt, gold, and equity. Don't want to venture out with a best idea yet because nothing looks too cheap or risk-free. Except Silver. Not too much risk there.

This FNO series is perplexing if one looks at old history of Nifty and Nifty stocks. Options are costlier compared to last few weeks but most liquid options, except Nifty's in June-July'13, are still staying much cheaper in May series if one cares to compare those to their 52 weeks' history. So if one considers last one year as a benchmark then not so much is going to happen in May.

This time again, I shall start with someone else's wisdom. A bearded philosopher has mentioned this very broad but useful risk framework in one of his books. We could learn a lot from his books including how to be an egoistic know-it-all. Stuff below is not from his book. I am just recalling stuff from multiple sources. He's inspiration. This is something that all investors and traders, even short term traders use mentally.

Known-Known - We all know (i.e. Market knows) that Modi is coming to power mid-May.  So we are not worried. Market could be higher in fact but for.... Monsoon may not be so good so let's hold on... 

Supposedly, market knows all of the above and much more. That's why there's euphoria but not too much. So Nifty at 6700 is justified or maybe even 7000 or maybe 6000 too. This is Mutual fund investor territory. Buying and selling does not matter much here.

Known-Un-known - We also know that India is a pretty crazy political place. BJP could get 200 seats but allies may not come through or with so many conditions that Govt could be crippled. What if Lalu becomes PM or Mamta becomes FM? So why buy so soon? Let's just pause, or even sell.

Sharp Investors and traders usually live in this part of the framework. And they move the markets every day based on 1 day to 1 decade forecasts. This is where option writers and buyers reside too. Now-a-days it looks like France in 1938's spring. Or maybe Punjab (pre-partition) in March 1947. Everything is green and sparrows are chirping as usual...

Knowing is not important. Buying Puts and forgetting your future imagined losses is more important. Maybe buying calls too. If there had not been a sustained bull market since July'13, I would have been advocating heavy buying of calls. I am looking for a mean-reversion. Not an actual forecast coming through for me. Nifty May 14 Calls - 7000, Puts - 6400. Buy them, forget till D-day. 


Un-known-Known - Everything is hunky-dory in rest of the world. Or is it? If they are not worrying why should I? S&P is trying to break all time highs. Europe, Japan is trying or already past 5 year highs. They should know so why should I care first. Is Putin done with Ukraine or is he going to do a 1936-38 Hitler? US will take care of it. What if North Korea launches a nuclear missile at South. They never have. 

Here too, buying puts makes sense. But only if one can sustain those kind of losses. The sheer inaction and boredom involved could kill more put buyers out there than both WWs put together. In case anyone wonders, I am not talking about active traders or hedgers. I am talking about those patient put buyers who hold till the last day of the series. Puts - 6000

Unknown-Unknown - Nuclear War? Comet? Socialist party of America in Senate? (those are known scenarios but no-one considers those possible. In fact unknowns cannot be thought of). Business of life cannot be conducted if we tried thinking of these. 

No body can buy puts or calls against these events. If they did, most would go dead or bankrupt before any got rich. The secret here is staying happy no matter what. Puts - 5200 (don't bother collecting in case of an extreme event)

Really short term thought at the end. What about May 12-20? If Nifty and Stock options were to shoot up sky high before May 12 ( eg VIX 50 or IVs of ICICI, SBI, RELIANCE, TATASTEEL, TATAMOTORS, RANBAXY, PNB, TATAMOTORS, DLF, BANKBARODA in 70-100 range), I would write. If much much lower, I would buy. Let's see what you do. You short term trader. You... 

Thursday, April 24, 2014

d) What are the risks now 



What are the risks now (MOST IMPORTANT! Its boring but this one you should miss at your own peril) - politics/ real estate/ global environment/

Just following up on my promise. But first I have to toot my horn. Being right is a good feeling so I have pasted below what I said 9th of March 2014

a) Market above 6400 - buy all dips through call options. Sell whenever market gives us 1% to 5%

Having tooted my horn, I have to get back to the topic. We have 3-5 weeks of election drama ahead of us. Technical stuff first.....

Option prices had sky-rocketed before 2009 elections. This time not so much. Nifty May options are twice as costly as April options but nothing compared to 5 years back.

Stock options are also not giving any hint of euphoria/ panic. Look at ICICI, SBI, RELIANCE, TATASTEEL, TATAMOTORS, DLF etc which are high beta stocks. These are liquid options. These are costlier for May series compared to April but not too much. Also look at INFY, TCS, RANBAXY, HINDUNILVR, ITC etc. Defensvies are only slightly more expensive compared to April. That's logical.

Basically market is bullish but not in euphoria or panic mode. So far so good. Labeling risk has become irrelevant because market is not pricing it. That's why no comment on political/ global risk. Real estate risk is a different animal that deserves a separate post.

The popular media is cautiously bullish. Which means that every one would want to trade on the long side. Saner thing to do would be to keep one's options open. 6000PE is 28 points and 8000CE is 10 points. One could benefit buying puts and selling twice as many of 8000 calls. 

Scared? Look at 3 year Nifty chart below and find some courage





Saturday, March 29, 2014

Sharekhan is going down. IndiaInfoline is next... Oops. I got it backward

Just one of those intuitive things that come about. In his or her infinite wisdom, God decided to mould me somewhat in the shape of Cassandra. We will deal with it when we meet again but there are more serious things afoot.

Peter Lynch sold millions of books. Premise - even a commoner can make money investing in common stocks. One of his points that pierced through many hearts and minds? Yes You! You can make indecent profits by observing your usual life and get some pointers. Its not that simple. It was just a feel good book that a first time investor should read. That too if he or she is below 30. After that the plot gets spoiled because you already know most of it.

Anyhoo... apart from some rumblings in the Private Equity circles this is what I know. Its inspired by Lynch so I had to mention him first.

a) Sharekhan has sent an ultimatum to lapsed users. Pay INR 10,000 PA or get booted out. About 7 years back some PE firm invested in SK based on the great number of "USERS" it had. SK has 90%+ lapsed users.
b) This is a clean up exercise. That's what SK says. It is more that that. Clean-up here means getting rid of last unproductive clients, employees, other unproductive assets.
c) After it gets rid of those useless assets, something will still be useful. Let me guess - Name, logo, active clients? Other assets?
d) Trading software belongs to FT and the hardware is old (Storage, Servers, Batteries, ACs, Room to store it all etc)

That's all.

Friday, March 28, 2014

c) How should a trader be trading now?

Really simple.

Go long if you can. That's if the fifth small wave of third big wave which is part of a major B.out allows you to get in at all. I should not paint a picture here. Some one else has been doing a great job of it for a long loong time. Just Nifty

Trading is simple. Its Risk-Reward. R-R. A look at the above chart will tell you that going long is bad on R-R. Going short is suicide. Vertical up move does not stop till it does. And when it does, we will know.

Day trader - can go long on dips. There are no clear levels for taking profits. Those levels are yet to be discovered. Every day market trends up, it does leave behind some levels. Those are fictional because this is a strong wave that yields 20-80 points dips to "unknown" points dips. Look at the chart below and decide for yourselves how futile it must have been for a patient trader to get in. On the other hand if someone does want to kiss death, the levels to get in are 6620-6600-6550. Below 6550 (spends few hours below this, not just a casual dip), the latest breakout of 6415 becomes suspect.

Medium term trader/ Swing trader - Above mentioned numbers are just stop loss numbers. There is no clear profit taking number. One could buy right now and keep a moving stop loss (moving up stop-loss) to make the most of these happy times.

Long term trader - No new members in this rare club. So no recommendation except holding your horses... longs.

Opportunists - Buy June 6000 puts and wait. Have the discipline to buy 1 put a day/ week depending on your loosing capacity. BTW the hedgers are buying 6000-6300 puts this month.








b) Is it too late for an new investor? 


What about the investor who was already invested in equities for the long term? (This is 2nd question from my 8th March post that I had promised to publish. So here it is)

The question is wrong. No one has to invest in equities. One can invest in anything - paintings (rich art collectors), Jewellery (Wives), Education (Students), NaMo (Voters). Those without a lighter vein in the body could invest in Real Estate, Debt, FDs, Gold, Commodities (if one could store these or invest through buying and selling futures).

If you could see the chart below, there is a long term channel breakout which should not have happened. It did however. Investors should enter near bottom of a channel or atleast significantly below its top. This Indian equity market is over-done for investors. China looks better. Don't know a single cost-effective vehicle of investing over there. If someone knows, could you mail me or leave a comment please? Long term investor can simply stay here as long as his or her equity takes up 20%-40% total assets minus one owned house. Equity over-owners (Forty plus people with 40% plus allocation in equity) have to sell some of their holdings now. Slowly perhaps and keeping it in mind that they will need to get back in again. It doesn't mean Indian equities won't make money. It could still give 10% pa easily. Could give more if there is a bubble (there is none yet). Equities are a really volatile class and one should not enter hoping for to barely beat inflation. Upside is limited and disappointment could be too great.

However consider below BS points too. All I am advocating here is that an Investor has to spread himself or herself across several asset classes.


  1. Gilts - Giving nearly 8.8% for 10 years period. Kind of low given inflation in India but not bad considering much lower risk. Buy direct if don't mind paying tax. Buy through direct MF (Not through bank, broker, agent) if you do pay tax. Those agents take away 0.5% to 1%. You don't want to pay that much when return is so low. Also when the investment is so mindless (Only one counterparty - Govt; How it makes money to return your money - none of your business. Aam khao, counting mat karo yaar) it just doesn't make sense to pay someone to diversify your risk. 
  2. Tax free bonds - Barely pays 8.3% - 8.9%. But no tax on income! Don't know when the next issue comes. Just a good avenue for a rich tax paying investor. A nice way of leaving something behind for your children.  
  3. Real Estate - Cooled off for last 1-2 years. Could remain so for another five years. However it beats inflation most of the times so if you have nothing in RE, there's still some sense in entering at these inflated levels. Like stocks, this also pays some rental/ dividend. Very low at 2-3 percent range but atleast it pays something. 
  4. Gold - Off its highs by nearly 15%. Still not cheap but not too shabby now. 
  5. Oil - You cannot invest because you can't take physical possession of it. 
  6. Water - this is real gold if it had a market. Buy a water purifier. Already have one? Get those filters cleaned. 
  7. Debt - If you want some excitement in life. Here it is. Nearly 2% incremental return over Gilts with more than commensurate risk. Enter through FMP, Long term MF route. You will sacrifice commission but gain in taxes. If you are a hot-shot who can't be bothered to pay taxes, go ahead an invest directly. Extra headache free, free, free.......
  8. Peace - Get some of it. Its priceless. 

PS: World is a nice place. These are good times and I am lucky to be alive right now. Please don't screw it up by leaving an abusive comment.


Monday, March 10, 2014

a) Is this 6400 Nifty break real...

Yes it is.

Logic gurus would demand a series of arguments leading upto a conclusion. A conclusion has no place at the beginning. However, an argument that comes with many if's and but's deserves a clear position beforehand.

+ its more to do with a speculater's mentality. One has to take a stand before one knows which way things are going to turn out.

Points in favor - Election rally (everyone knows it), FIIs made it go up (as usual), Normal investor was against the idea, VIX is low, Banks are leading the rally (70% weightage)

Points against - VIX started rising on the day of rally instead of going down further, Nifty valuations are not attractive, Pharma and IT dipped (portfolio rebalancing?), Too much stock manipulation (ICICI, RIL, Bharti were the first horses galloping off the gates), Likes of DheelaLF and JPAss posted best gains for the day however. (30% weightage)

Can't resist the temptation of quoting a dear former boss here... "hawa mein sukhe patte sabse unche udte hain (wind sweeps the dry leaves highest)". Seconds before his quote some time in May 2004, I was making an argument about buying Tata Steel versus SAIL to a numerically smart colleague I liked. I was talking fundamentals but my boss' motherhood statement was way more effective because it was succinct and in-your-face. Despite having learnt the value of brevity from masters, I intend to go on and on here. At the risk of sounding right, you could say that I have learned nothing from history.

This breakout of 6415 Nifty has already been labelled an "Election rally". Elections are due in April-May and results will be out before May series expiry. Label is not important. Time is though. 29th May (end of May series) should be a date we must not forget. All my ramblings below assume that life does not exist beyond May 2014.

I am not so sure of Nifty but VIX for March, April and May series should keep on rising from here on. This market has rewarded option sellers for nearly 6 months. It's an option buyer's market right now. Not because I say so or I am full of it. It's just practical wisdom that a range-bound market goes a long way once it decides to break out. Either way. And once it does, it just keeps going on and on.

A breakout means nothing if it can not be defended by people who are invested in it. FIIs have made it go up and they will have to consistently pour in money to make it stay that way. Its a well understood fact that FIIs "Buy-up" assets. Real fundamental driven stock pickers should ideally wait years for market to fall to reasonable levels but normally they don't. Its opium (OPM-OtherPeoples'Money) that has to be driven through the senseless brain called market. In those circles they don't exactly think that they should wait for the right moment. The right moment happens when a) somebody invests in your fund, b) you decide that India deserves 0.1% of additional allocation this year on a portfolio basis. Rest is jargon that your financial adviser can best fill you up on.

So what makes it real? Next few days, that's all. Time is the best teacher. If market dips back to 6400 or even 6000 level this series, its just an opportunity to buy for traders. They will do so. Guys who are actually going to keep it up are FIIs and let's keep an eye on their positions on a daily basis. If they are not buying the India story (don't listen to news channel, just listen to numbers) then no one else is going to. That should be our primary leading indicator - FII investment in equity, futures.

The rest of it has to be based on instinct and some self-imposed numbers.

6415 is one of those numbers. We must buy dips towards this magical figure and sell whenever we manage to eke out 1-5 percent profits. Yes I know. Range is too wide because 1% is all you should hope for in a rangebound market. Five percent is something you should expect on a weekly basis however in a breakout market.

6300 +/- 100 is a range of numbers. None of those matter but those will get talked about a lot. Think of this 200 point range as if it's a foam mattress. Or a sea of molasses. Prices could fall into this, bounce about, slush around like they are trapped ice-cubes in an overflowing cup of thick syrupy slush. Whatever gets your imagination. But recognize it as the graveyard of actively trading people. This is where people come to sacrifice their hard-earned money at the alter of goddess Lakshmi. This should be option writers paradise. 

6100-5900. This is also a vague range. Nothing happens here except bullish people get convinced they got a bargain and bears think they have one last opportunity to make easy money. Up of this range is pure slush but down could be attractive. Pure option play. Buy May/ June straddles and forget about it. If you make a killing, your broker won't call you because you had no margin to begin with.

5850 and below. This is tempestuous. Things get bearish here but don't count on easy profits. Markets get yo-yo here. If you are a long term investor, you could start buying here. If a shortie, you could just write options on both sides. If this stage would ever come back again, don't be shy. VIX above 20 will automatically give you the clue. If VIX is 18-minus however, don't bother. Staying out of market is a always a good choice. 

5200 and below. This is the dreamland for investors. If market ever falls below this region, buy. Buy. In fact, take a loan against your house and buy. Nifty may not go up for several years but an FII dominated market rarely falls to these levels. When it does, do not hesitate. Institutional investors should not have all the fun. Average Indian Investor (AII) should also get some.

6415+ is not an investor friendly zone. Call options make sense here. Buy on dips and exit on a nice trend day, Eg 7th March was a good day to discard longs in last one hour. Now that day is gone so all one can do is to buy on dips towards 6450 and keep an SL near 6400. Participate through options because it's an unknown territory. Options are still cheap so why not have fun at the expense of writers while we still can. They had a five month spring and it could finally be turn of trend tradres and big-return chasers now.

Not all of us live in dreamland however. Market reveals prices and preferences. It hardly ever reveals risk. VIX is a proxy but I have seen Nifty doing a 100 point move twice a week too often while VIX was 16 +/- 2. Two extreme days every week kind of tell you that this low VIX number does not deserve respect. I have the following bullshit points to support my argument. (Oops... bullet, not bullshit)

a) Market above 6400 - buy all dips through call options. Sell whenever market gives us 1% to 5%
b) Market dips below 6400 but gets bought up and stays above 6400 - Not only do above but also short 6000 puts to raise funds for those aggressive 6600CE options.
c) Market dips below 6400 and stays there for 3 sessions - watch VIX. If it's 18 or more, start writing options, if not just watch the beauty of candle charts.
d) Market stays in 6000-6400 range for some time and then gently breaks down. Buy back puts. Buy 5500 puts if not too costly.
e)   Market opens 10 to 20 percent down and hits circuit breaker. Book your losses first. Then start investing. Call your stock broker/ Mom/ Dad/ Spouse/ Sibling/ Friends. Tell them you have a great investment idea and they should all get in. That God personally visited you in your dream and told you that you had a responsibility to your fellow beings. The responsibility to make them rich. If you are anything like me, you might actually do something like that. If you are not, then you could wait for the next business cycle. Or maybe you could tell your kids about it.