Tuesday, September 6, 2016

Who's the real expert - CNBC TV 18 - 4 experts, 16 recommendations

It was 24th December 2015. CNBC TV 18 was broadcasting an investors' summit with 4 experts being anchored by Sonia Shenoy. Each expert - Tulsian, Porinju, Ambareesh and Prakash Diwan - had to talk about 4 long term multibagger picks of theirs.

Normally I don't listen to investor summits. Ever. Somehow, on a whim, I decided to watch it, note down the recommendations made, and compare performance of the expert recommendations after enough time had elapsed. I already have some favourites based no my gut feel but I thought let's subject them to a quantitative test to see if numbers justify my assessment. 

The detailed table of analysis is given below but first the summary of analysis for impatient readers.

Basis average, it seems Porinju Veliyath is the best expert among the famous four. However, Porinju is not as consistent a hitter as Mr Tulsian or Mr Baliga. His average is pulled up by Biocon, the best of 16 recommendations. Moreover he weakened his own case for title of best expert by mentioning that he is considering owning it but has not bought it yet. But he is a winner nevertheless. Sort of a batsman who follows 3 average innings with a double century.

That leaves SP Tulsian in next top spot who's outperformed Nifty 50 by 14%. Ambareesh has himself beaten Nifty 50 by a healthy 10%. Given that they gave just 4 recommendations, there is no statistical edge here but Mr Tulsian gets the 2nd spot based on pure numbers and nothing else.

Mind it though ;-) that performance is often measured in terms of risk-reward ratio and given lower variance in calls given by Mr Tulsian and Mr Baliga, any one of them could climb to top spot. However, once again, a small sample of 4 makes it impossible to determine a proxy for this ratio.

What's baffling is Prakash Diwan's performance. He's actually underperformed Nifty 50 by 6%; a nightmarish scenario if you happen to follow his recommendations. What's really pulled him down is his Dion Global recommendation which really did badly. Even without that though, he still ends up last, so the prize for worst recommendations goes to him. Anyone billionaire investing solely based on his recommendations, could find himself just a millionaire in a few years. 

It was personally very interesting for me to do this analysis. Based on my intuition, I have always placed SP Tulsian up there at the top and Ambareesh Baliga a little lower. And I always had suspicions that Prakash Diwan often produces half assed guesses and sometimes his analysis seems dishonest. But that was just a gut feel. It was gratifying to see that my intuition has been spot on. I have never followed Porinju and did not know what he could pull off. He definitely has a different way of making decisions compared to my other favourites so it makes sense that I track him too in future (only when he speaks directly. A number of times, other people attribute stuff to him which might be completely made up). 

Before you read the table below and make up your own mind about which one to pick for your own portfolio, just remember that winners of last 36 weeks are more likely to be the winners for next 3-10 years as well. Please don't fall for the cheap stuff automatically.

Personally I am going to add the following to my portfolio. No need to add Biocon as it has been there in my portfolio for almost a year.

  1. Jain Irrigation - current portfolio weak on agriculture theme so need to add this.
  2. Tata Global - apart from Porinju's argument that Cyrus Mistry might want to turn around this company (he might), coffee prices are also bottoming out for last 2 years, which can give an added boost during next 1-2 years, whenever coffee crop goes bad in a key grower country. Already have it. To add more.
  3. Anant Raj - here I am simply going by Porinju's assessment that company is real estate rich. Even in the best of days for real estate - pre 2008 - this company did not make money for shareholders in line with its valuations. 



No comments:

Post a Comment